Investigation of Kinetic Electron and Ion Transport
Effects in Inertial Confinement Fusion Experiments at
NIF and OMEGA
Name
reichelt-blr-phd-physics-2026-thesis.pdf
Size
10.6 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
2301973ac130dd50f9574dba680281cc
Author(s)
Reichelt, Benjamin L.
Advisor(s)
Li, Chikang
Date Issued
February 2026
Publisher
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Abstract
The overarching goal of Inertial Confinement Fusion (ICF) is to compress energy in time and space to a great enough extent that the coulomb barrier repelling nuclei is overcome and nuclear fusion can occur in significant quantities. However, the history of the field has shown this goal to be significantly more challenging than originally expected, and significant work has been done to develop analytical and numerical frameworks to explain results seen in experiment. Historically, these models have utilized fluid models where the plasma has a well-defined temperature and velocity at each point in space, but these conditions are not always a given in ICF experiments, sometimes necessitating use of more expensive multifluid or kinetic models. This work focuses on several projects where these more complicated models have been shown to be necessary to explain experimental data. The first project discussed in this work utilizes thin-shell, shock-driven OMEGA separated reactant experiments to observe a novel kinetic mix mechanism in ICF implosions. Time resolved D3He-p reaction history data demonstrate a 50(20) ps shift earlier in peak nuclear emission for separated reactant experiments relative to control, in contrast to past experimental data for thicker shells that show a 75 ps delay due to the time required for hydrodynamic instabilities to develop. Ion kinetic simulations utilizing fall line analyses show much closer agreement with mix yield and temperature than diffusion models, predicting a D3He-p mix yield of 1.7 × 109 as compared to the experimental value of 9.3(±2.1) × 108 . This is much closer than the fall line analysis from a hydrodynamic simulation with an inline diffusive mix model, which suggests minimal mix and D3He-p yields of 5 × 105 . An analytical model suggests that significant kinetic mix can be carried by supra-thermal particles even in situations when the shell expands significantly to low densities and diffusive models predict negligible mix. Taking into account this kinetic mix mechanism is essential for high adiabat, high implosion velocity experiments as the subsequent mix can change the mass of the hot spot and introduce high-Z impurities that are detrimental to a favorable power balance. The second project discussed in this thesis describes the impact of spontaneously generated magnetic fields in the hohlraum on hot electron transport using a Monte Carlo simulation. A 2D MHD simulation was performed to obtain density and magnetic field maps of high fill (1.6 mg/cc He) and low fill (0.6 mg/cc He) hohlraums, indicating magnetic fields of strength ∼ 100 kG are present at the laser entrance window where hot electrons are generated during the picket. These fields have different morphologies and strengths for the high and low fill hohlraums, resulting in a 5× increase in the axial beaming fraction of the hot electrons predicted by a Monte Carlo simulations when going from high to low fill. This matches the trend seen in experiment while remaining consistent with the prediction from simulations that densities in the window are too low to support isotropic hot electron generation Two Plasmon Decay. Taking into account the effect of magnetic fields on electron transport also explains an increase in beaming fraction experimentally observed as hot electron number increases and the magnetic field of the hot electrons begins to provide a focusing mechanism. Next, we explore aspects of direct alpha-ion heating through comparison of a one-fluid and two-fluid power balance model of the hot spot. We show that the case with all alpha energy deposited in electrons raises the ignition criteria by ∼ 4 keV or ∼ 0.2 g/cm2 in the hot spot relative to the case with all alpha energy deposited in ions. In the case of recently ignited NIF implosions, 30% of the 3.5 MeV 𝛼 energy is deposited into the DT fuel ions, for which there is negligible difference between the one-fluid and two-fluid ignition criteria. However, changes in the ion stopping fraction through profile effects and alternate stopping power models could lead to ignition curve shifts of ∼ 1 keV. The fourth project discusses the development of a new diagnostic to measure low-yield nuclear burn histories at the National Ignition Facility, and utilizes burn history measurements to prove the importance of multispecies hohlraum effects on modeling the stagnation of hohlraum flows. The Particle Time of Flight (PTOF) diagnostic is a Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) diamond-based detector and is the only diagnostic for measuring nuclear bang times of low yield (< 1013) shots on the National Ignition Facility (NIF). Recently, a comprehensive study of detector impulse responses revealed certain detectors with very fast and consistent impulse response with a rise time of < 50 ps, enabling low yield burn history measurements. At the current standoff of 50 cm, this measurement is possible with fast 14 MeV neutrons from deuterium-tritium (DT) fusion plasmas. PTOF-inferred DT burn width numbers agree within 50 ps with widths inferred from the Gamma Reaction History (GRH) diagnostic on mid-yield (1013 − 1015) shots, where both systems are capable of making this measurement. This burn width measurement capability is utilized on a novel NIF shot with a DT hohlraum fill to measure the stagnation of flows in the hohlraum. It is found that the PTOF measured burn history agrees well with the predicted burn history from a multi-species hohlraum simulation, and significantly differs with the history from a single-species simulation. Finally, in the last chapter, we discuss a novel, conservative algorithm for treating self heating in fusion plasmas kinetically. Accurate treatment of energetic fusion byproducts in laboratory plasmas often requires a kinetic description, owing to their large birth kinetic energy and long mean-free-paths compared with the characteristic system scale lengths. For example, alpha particles produced by deuterium–tritium fusion reactions are born at high energies (3.5 MeV) and predominantly slow down through interactions with electrons traveling at comparable speeds. As an alpha particle slows, its distribution collapses near the background ion-thermal speed, forming a sharp structure in velocity space. Such sharp features pose numerical challenges in grid-based Eulerian methods: capturing the full alphaparticle energies demands a large velocity domain, while resolving the near-thermal region requires a sufficiently fine mesh. Inspired by the work of Peigney et al. [J. Comput. Phys. 278 (2014)], we present a two-grid approach that splits the alpha-particle distribution into energetic (suprathermal) and ash (thermal) components. A Gaussian-based sink term transfers particles from the energetic population to the ash population as they slow to the thermal regime, and a conservative projection scheme ensures that mass, momentum, and energy of the alpha and ash interactions are preserved. Unlike the formulation of Peigney, our method does not require a strict asymptotic separation of velocity scales, which can, in principle, be arbitrary. We demonstrate the robustness of this approach on challenging multiscale problems, including ignited capsules in inertial confinement fusion systems.
MIT Department
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Department of Physics
Terms of Use
Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)
Copyright retained by author(s)
Persistent DSpace Link