Dynamic choices are most accurate in small groups
Name
12080_2017_Article_349.pdf
Size
3.91 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
fc3adff4a3713d7f0ba9bb370f879d4c
Author(s)
Vicente-Page, Julián
de Polavieja, Gonzalo G.
Perez Escudero, Alfonso
Date Issued
October 2017
Journal
Theoretical Ecology
Publisher
Springer Netherlands
Citation
Vicente-Page, Julián, et al. “Dynamic Choices Are Most Accurate in Small Groups.” Theoretical Ecology, vol. 11, no. 1, Mar. 2018, pp. 71–81. © 2017 The Authors
Version
Final published version
Abstract
According to the classic results of Galton and Condorcet, as well as in modern decision-making models, accuracy in groups increases with group size. However, these studies do not consider the naturally occurring situation in which individuals dynamically re-evaluate their decision with a possible change of opinion. The dynamics of re-evaluation in groups are very different to individual re-evaluation because individuals influence the group and the group influences the individual. We find that individual accuracy in a group is higher when individuals re-evaluate because all members have more access to social information, while in single decisions, those deciding first have less. This improvement is smaller in large groups as in this case errors can cascade across the members of the group before re-evaluation can correct them. The net result is a maximal accuracy at a small group size. We also analyzed the case in which individuals are influenced only by a small number of the other individuals. In this case, cascading errors affect the interacting subgroups but are very unlikely to reach the whole group. This results in a local optimum at a small group size but also an optimum at a very large size. We thus suggest that re-evaluation dynamics can make small and very large groups optimal. Also, features that may be seen as limitations, like an influence from only a small number of individuals, may turn to be beneficial when considering local animal interactions, here filtering out cascading of errors in the group when reconsideration dynamics takes place. Keywords: Collective behavior, Collective decisions, Dynamic decisions
MIT Department
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Department of Physics
Terms of Use
Creative Commons Attribution
Persistent DSpace Link
DOI of Published Version
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12080-017-0349-9
