The Grice Is Right: Grice's Non‐Cooperation Problem and the Structure of Conversation
Name
Philosophical Perspectives - 2025 - Berstler - The Grice Is Right Grice s Non‐Cooperation Problem and the Structure of.pdf
Size
260.55 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
fccc91ec949368a8cce1df96979702bd
Author(s)
Berstler, Sam
Date Issued
May 26, 2025
Journal
Philosophical Perspectives
Publisher
Wiley
Citation
Berstler, S.. 2024. “ The Grice Is Right: Grice's Non-Cooperation Problem and the Structure of Conversation.” Philosophical Perspectives 38, no. 1: 38, 26–40.
Version
Final published version
Abstract
H. P. Grice seemed to rest his theory of conversational implicature on the assumption that speakers aim to cooperatively exchangeinformation with each other. In the real world, speakers often don’t. Does one of the most influential theories in 20th-centuryphilosophy of language rest on a mistake? Yes—but not in the way that philosophers have thought. I argue that Grice shouldhave rested his theory on a different assumption: that speakers aim to appear to aim to cooperatively exchange informationwith each other. This proposal dissolves Grice’s Non-Cooperation Problem but preserves Grice’s central insights about the natureof conversational implicatures. More generally, it enables the Gricean to illuminate the structure of many non-cooperative orotherwise “non-ideal” conversations.
MIT Department
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Department of Linguistics and Philosophy
Terms of Use
Creative Commons Attribution
Persistent DSpace Link
DOI of Published Version
https://doi.org/10.1111/phpe.12199
