The perils of peer effects
Name
w19774.pdf
Size
652.27 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
71a4f0cc226b161106720fa58adf0b62
Author(s)
Angrist, Joshua
Date Issued
June 2014
Journal
Labour Economics
Publisher
Elsevier
Citation
Angrist, Joshua D. “The Perils of Peer Effects.” Labour Economics 30 (October 2014): 98–108 © 2014 Elsevier B.V.
Version
Original manuscript
Abstract
Individual outcomes are highly correlated with group average outcomes, a fact often interpreted as a causal peer effect. Without covariates, however, outcome-on-outcome peer effects are vacuous, either unity or, if the average is defined as a leave-out mean, determined by a generic intraclass correlation coefficient. When pre-determined peer characteristics are introduced as covariates in a model linking individual outcomes with group averages, the question of whether peer effects or social spillovers exist is econometrically identical to that of whether a 2SLS estimator using group dummies to instrument individual characteristics differs from OLS estimates of the effect of these characteristics. The interpretation of results from models that rely solely on chance variation in peer groups is therefore complicated by bias from weak instruments. With systematic variation in group composition, the weak IV issue falls away, but the resulting 2SLS estimates can be expected to exceed the corresponding OLS estimates as a result of measurement error and for other reasons unrelated to social effects. Research designs that manipulate peer characteristics in a manner unrelated to individual characteristics provide the most compelling evidence on the nature of social spillovers. As an empirical matter, designs of this sort have mostly uncovered little in the way of socially significant causal effects. Keywords: causality; social returns; instrumental variables
MIT Department
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Department of Economics
Terms of Use
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike
Persistent DSpace Link
DOI of Published Version
https://doi.org/10.1016/J.LABECO.2014.05.008
