A Bunch of Gaps: Factors Behind Service Reliability in Chicago’s High-Frequency Transit Network

Abstract

Frequent transit services in urban areas have the potential to increase their accessibility to transit-dependent riders and reduce congestion by attracting new ridership through a modal shift. However, bus services operating in mixed traffic face operational challenges that reduce reliability and hinder their attractiveness. The sources of unreliability can range from local-level conditions, like the road infrastructure, to higher-level decisions, like the service plan. For the effective planning of improvement strategies, both scales of analysis must be considered. This paper uses a novel modeling framework to understand reliability by analyzing the route and segment factors separately. The Chicago Transit Authority (CTA) bus network is used as a case study for the analysis. The data reflect the operational, demand, and urban conditions of 50 high-frequency bus routes. At the route level, we use the coefficient of headway variation as the dependent variable and diverse route characteristics as explanatory variables. The results indicate that the most significant contributors to the variability of headways are variability in schedules and dispatching at terminals. It is also found that driver experience impacts reliability and that east–west routes are more unreliable than north–south routes. At the segment level, we use data from trips involved in bunching and gaps. As the dependent variable, a novel measure is formulated to capture how quickly bunching or gaps are formed. The bunching and gap events are treated as separate regression models. Findings suggest that link and dwell time variability are the most significant contributors to gap and bunching formation. In terms of infrastructure, bus lane segments reduce gap formations, and left turns increase bunching and gap formations. The insights presented can inform improvements in service and transit infrastructure planning to improve transit level of service (LOS) and support the future of sustainable, smart cities.