Characterization and Improvement of the Clinical Assessment of Vocal Hyperfunction

Abstract

Vocal hyperfunction refers to "conditions of abuse and/or misuse of the vocal mechanism due to excessive and/or 'imbalanced' muscular forces" (Hillman, Holmberg, Perkell, Walsh, & Vaughan, 1989), characterized by excessive laryngeal and paralaryngeal tension (Aronson, 1980; M. D. Morrison, Rammage, Belisle, Pullan, & Nichol, 1983; N. Roy, Ford, & Bless, 1996). There is no widely accepted diagnostic measure of the presence and degree of vocal hyperfunction, and currently, assessment during diagnosis is often primarily based on subjective impressions given the patient's history and presentation of symptoms such as auditory-perceptual and visual or tactile discrimination of muscle tension (e.g., laryngeal palpation). Clinical care is hindered by the lack of a "gold standard" objective measure for the assessment of vocal hyperfunction. The first study in this thesis evaluated a novel experimental design for the study of vocal hyperfunction, making use of the established clinical procedure of injection laryngoplasty. This work found that the use of injection laryngoplasty as a platform for the study of some types of vocal hyperfunction is limited, but may offer a convenient opportunity to study selected associated parameters. Particular promising objective measures were investigated in the remaining four studies: kinematics of the vocal folds, root-mean-squared (RMS) measures of surface electromyography (sEMG), and spectral characteristics of sEMG. Kinematic features of vocal fold abduction and adduction were shown to discriminate between individuals with muscle tension dysphonia and controls.

(cont.) RMS measures of sEMG were investigated through correlation with current clinical neck palpation techniques in voice therapy patients and via a cross-sectional study of individuals with vocal fold nodules. Correlations between RMS neck sEMG and palpation ratings were low, and although some individuals with nodules displayed RMS neck sEMG patterns that were inconsistent with those seen in controls, overall the RMS measures were unable to discriminate between disordered and control groups. Mean coherence between two neck sEMG locations in individuals with vocal nodules was significantly lower in the 15 - 35 Hz band relative to controls, possibly agreeing with past subjective accounts of "imbalanced" muscle activity.