MIT Libraries logoDSpace@MIT

MIT
View Item 
  • DSpace@MIT Home
  • MIT Open Access Articles
  • MIT Open Access Articles
  • View Item
  • DSpace@MIT Home
  • MIT Open Access Articles
  • MIT Open Access Articles
  • View Item
JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

Sources of Cost Overrun in Nuclear Power Plant Construction Call for a New Approach to Engineering Design

Author(s)
Eash-Gates, Philip; Klemun, Magdalena M.; Kavlak, Goksin; McNerney, James M; Buongiorno, Jacopo; Trancik, Jessika; ... Show more Show less
Thumbnail
DownloadAccepted version (334.4Kb)
Publisher with Creative Commons License

Publisher with Creative Commons License

Creative Commons Attribution

Terms of use
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Metadata
Show full item record
Abstract
© 2020 Elsevier Inc. Nuclear plant costs in the US have repeatedly exceeded projections. Here, we use data covering 5 decades and bottom-up cost modeling to identify the mechanisms behind this divergence. We observe that nth-of-a-kind plants have been more, not less, expensive than first-of-a-kind plants. “Soft” factors external to standardized reactor hardware, such as labor supervision, contributed over half of the cost rise from 1976 to 1987. Relatedly, containment building costs more than doubled from 1976 to 2017, due only in part to safety regulations. Labor productivity in recent plants is up to 13 times lower than industry expectations. Our results point to a gap between expected and realized costs stemming from low resilience to time- and site-dependent construction conditions. Prospective models suggest reducing commodity usage and automating construction to increase resilience. More generally, rethinking engineering design to relate design variables to cost change mechanisms could help deliver real-world cost reductions for technologies with demanding construction requirements. Nuclear power plants provide roughly half of the low-carbon electricity in the US. However, projections of nuclear plant costs have repeatedly failed to predict the cost overruns observed since the 1960s. We study the mechanisms that have contributed to the rise in nuclear construction costs over the past 5 decades to understand the divergence between expected and realized costs. We find that nth-of-a-kind plants in the US have been more expensive than first-of-a-kind plants, with “soft” factors external to reactor hardware contributing over half of the cost increase between 1976 and 1987. Costs of the reactor containment building more than doubled, primarily due to declining on-site labor productivity. Productivity in recent US plants is up to 13 times lower than industry expectations. A prospective analysis of the containment building suggests that improved materials and automation could increase the resilience of nuclear construction costs to variable conditions. We study nuclear plant costs in the US over the past 5 decades to understand the mechanisms that contributed to cost escalation and the repeated underestimation of construction cost. We show that declining labor productivity and “soft” costs were leading contributors. Counter to expectation, nth-of-a-kind plants have been more expensive than first-of-a-kind plants. Our prospective analysis of the containment building suggests that the cost resilience of nuclear construction could be increased through improved materials and automation.
Date issued
2020-11
URI
https://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/133049
Department
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Institute for Data, Systems, and Society; Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Department of Nuclear Science and Engineering
Journal
Joule
Publisher
Elsevier BV
Citation
East-Gates, Philip et al. "Sources of Cost Overrun in Nuclear Power Plant Construction Call for a New Approach to Engineering Design" Joule 4, 11 (November 2020): 2348-2373. © 2020 Elsevier Inc.
Version: Author's final manuscript
ISSN
2542-4351

Collections
  • MIT Open Access Articles

Browse

All of DSpaceCommunities & CollectionsBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjects

My Account

Login

Statistics

OA StatisticsStatistics by CountryStatistics by Department
MIT Libraries
PrivacyPermissionsAccessibilityContact us
MIT
Content created by the MIT Libraries, CC BY-NC unless otherwise noted. Notify us about copyright concerns.